Re(View): City of Dreadful Night ~ Ensemble Stage

A play about Love, Memory, & Cherry Pie

This weekend and next, I will be playing the role of Philly in Ensemble Stage’s production of City of Dreadful Night by Don Nigro. It may seem disingenuous for one of the actors to be reviewing their performance, and fair enough, but there aren’t many people writing reviews of plays these days, particularly in rural areas. Also, to be an actor I have to be aware of myself and how I fit into the larger body of work at all times. So, I can be relatively objective.

I am having a lot of fun. It is the most fulfilling performance I’ve done in a while. I have worked with the company for four years, and it is something of an artist’s paradise. Cool weather, an amazing facility, and an organic atmosphere inside the organization and out around town. Finally, I am acting in a Mainstage production, and I am excited to have the challenge of working alongside other actors who are crowd-favorites here in Banner Elk, NC. I feel right at home onstage; it helps that Nigro wrote this piece to feel natural (at least for my character). Philly works the late shift at the diner which the other characters frequent. We don’t know a lot about him until the end, so I can’t spoil anything for you – you have to come see the play in person for that information.


What I like about playing Philly is finding the moments where he thinks himself a tough guy, but quickly retracts like a puppy around the big boys. Within each scene, you get glimpses of different sides of him. In my brain, I am channeling some of Paulie Walnuts and Chrissy Moltisanti of The Sopranos along with my partner’s extended family and a dash of Seinfeld’s Jack Klompus. This mostly helped me find the cadence and nuances of the dialects of specifically that sort of New York voice, but sometimes helped figure out how Philly moves and how he reacts to stress. Of course, there were moments still hard to pin how best to interpret the writing, and Director Gary Smith was extraordinarily helpful through his insight into the character and (as a good director should) often found something better hidden inside the beat.

“I can almost remember. But it’s all mixed up. It’s all fragments. they don’t connect up right. It’s like somebody dropped a puzzle on the floor…and this fog has got in my head. - Tony

Nigro has written quite a few pieces related or inspired by historical figures and works of art, including this play inspired by Edward Hopper’s Nighthawks painting. Set in New York City at the end of the1940s, this piece features would-be gangsters who are trying to piece together the fate of a friend from the past. It is a dark, funny, seductive story that had me guessing who-dunnit up through the last page when I first read it. And, cherry pie comes up quite a bit throughout the scenes. I’m still not completely sure what that’s about.

The story is centered around two old-school New Yorkers, Gus & Tony, and Gus’s girlfriend Anna. Tony “don’t remember things too good since the war” and Gus has him following Anna around. (Gus was also in the war – WWII if you didn’t guess). Anna wants to know about a photo she has seen with these two men and some girl. There are twists, turns, and more twists with a constant threat of violence; some foul language; echoing thoughts among characters; and that pie keeps getting mentioned. Lucky for you there will be something for your sweet tooth at intermission.

My onstage counterparts (Shanel Sparr, Scott Wilson, and Mark Allen Woodard) are all excellent performers whose ability to control the room leads to great moments onstage. Shanel in particular is captivating as Anna, especially when she puts pressure on the others; the rest of us have no choice but to build off her energy (she gives me chills during each run). Scott and Mark have fed off each other in scenes for 6 productions now, and audiences love to see them together. This play is a great example of why they are so often paired together at Ensemble Stage.

There are moments in City of Dreadful Night that are hard to watch due to the violent nature of its subject and actions, but I find myself unable to look away. This is not very helpful to me when I am onstage at the same time, supposedly in a completely different building. It takes a lot of work for me to ignore the performances of my castmates, but you have no reason to do so when you are in the audience.

City of Dreadful Night will open tonight (July 21) at 7:30 PM. You have two weekends plus a Tuesday evening (July 25) to see it. If you are a fan of mystery, especially in the classic film noir style, this play is right up your alley. If you prefer another genre of shows, there is plenty for you, too. The dialogue between the characters provides both unsettling drama and absurd comedy to balance the action and mystery. And did I mention there would be pie? There are so many reasons to see this play; I hope I have given you enough to convince you it will be worth your while to join us.

City of Dreadful Night at Ensemble Stage runs July 21-30, in Banner Elk, NC.

The artistic team for the production is: Director Gary Smith, Production Manager & Props/Costume Designer Lisa Lamont, Set Designer Michael Helms, Lighting Designer John Marty, Master Electrician Kaili Boyd, Stage Manager Nicole Pehan, Technical Director Yours Truly (wink wink).

See you there? Tickets here: Ensemble Stage on Tix

PS: Coming from out of town and interested in staying overnight? Learn about our Stay & Play package options, which bundles two adult tickets with a hotel stay. You’ll end up saving on both ends compared to if you had purchased them all individually. 

Follow Ensemble Stage on Instagram for more theatre in your feed! @ensemblestage ->